More attention can be given to Singaporeans who are “done” with religion, or are never religious

More attention can be given to Singaporeans who are “done” with religion, or are never religious

A Commentary by the Humanist Society (Singapore)

The Humanist Society (Singapore) welcomes The Straits Times’ in-depth interview with Dr Melvin Tay on Singapore’s changing religious landscape (Are Singaporeans losing faith in organised religion? 04 November 2026).

We are heartened that the Straits Times devoted around 50 minutes to this topic. Such discussions are good for Singapore, a country with one of the highest non-religious percentages in Southeast Asia (behind Vietnam), currently at 23.9% of Singapore’s resident population in 2025. 

The Humanist Society (Singapore) has spent the past 16 years engaging with non-religious individuals across Singapore. Over this period, we have held 400+ events and documented numerous personal stories, giving us valuable insights into the diverse journeys of the non-religious community in Singapore. 

Based on our experience, we feel that more attention can be given to Singaporeans who are “done” with religion, or were “never” religious. This would provide a balance to the angle that the non-religious people are “still religious”. 

Dr Tay cited findings from the Institute of Policy Studies (IPS) that less than half, around 40%, of non-religious respondents still believe in a higher being (at 3:00). He observed, “Even though people are more likely to be less religiously affiliated, it doesn’t mean that they are less religious.” (at 17:30)

We understand that one of these findings comes from the IPS working paper, Religion in Singapore: The Private and Public Spheres in 2019 (sample of 1,800 Singapore residents). An extract of figures from the non-religious reveal “half to less than half” of the non-religious still believe in religion or the supernatural (see Annex below for exact figures).

We also note 2023 findings from the Pew Research Center that indicate that 87% of Singaporean adults surveyed believe in God or unseen beings (sample size 2,036). This reinforces the earlier finding that slightly less than half (~45%) of the 23.9% non-religious Singaporeans still believe in the supernatural.

The other half matters too

Dr Tay is right that nuances matter when studying non-religiousity among Singaporeans. We would like to add that the interview also needs to include the other half who do not believe in a higher being. There needs to be a recognition that among the religiously unaffiliated (“nones”), many are firm about leaving (“dones”) or never joining religion (“nevers”). They are essentially “done” with religion or “never” wanted to join religion. 

For many of the “dones” / “nevers”, not having a religion is not simply about a lack of time, dissatisfaction with religious institutions, or fear of commitment. They have rejected not just religious beliefs but also religious epistemology (how we know things). Key epistemologies among many religious traditions include revelation and divine authority.

In the events we held, we spoke to many “dones” – Few want to return to the faith they left because their disagreement with religious teachings is at a much deeper and personal level. As they no longer wish to see the world through the lens of a religion, having greater convenience, changing methods of worship, or additional benefits will not restore religiosity. . 

We observe that most people who are done with or were never religious generally lead busy and productive lives similar to most Singaporeans today. They are focused on growing their careers, caring for their families, pursuing their hobbies. They follow the news keenly, discuss often with their friends, and are capable of concern for the marginalised, expressing sadness over wars and natural disasters abroad. When asked, many express hope for a better world. 

They just don’t need religion anymore. 

Leaving Religion Does Not Mean Abandoning Commitment or Identities

Dr Tay suggested that Singapore’s fast-paced lifestyle makes sustained religious participation more difficult (at 16:10). We feel that this might not fully account for religious disaffiliation across the globe. While there is no objective measurement for “pace of life”, countries widely regarded as having a slower pace of life than Singapore, such as Australia, Sweden, Czechia, also experienced dropping religious affiliation over the past few decades. 

On the growing reluctance of committing to religious institutions, Dr Tay also said, “We are nowadays less willing to commit to anything in general,” citing falling marriages, lesser kids etc. (43:50)

Declining religious affiliation does not necessarily reflect a weakening commitment to meaningful pursuits. People continue to invest considerable effort in families, careers, friendships, volunteering and personal development. Among the youth and younger adults, there is rising awareness of the need for sustainability, mental health and lifelong learning. 

Dr Tay also highlighted this trend: “Among those who still ascribe to a religion they have gotten more religious.” (21:59)

The reference would be an IPS Study on “Religious Identity and Practice Among Singaporeans” in 2025. The study found that nearly three-quarters (about 73.7%) of Singaporeans with a religious affiliation consider their faith central to their identity, showing an increase compared to past survey waves. See table 2.1 below, rightmost column:

Source: Page 19 of Religious Identity and Practice Among Singaporeans

The table shows that the number of (religious) people who see religion as important for their identity is increasing. However, that is also true for every other item in the list, such as identifying by nationality / language / race / mother tongue etc. 

So this not just religion is becoming more important, but identity itself is becoming more important. If this is true, the “dones” can also be recognised in their non-religious identity.

Moving forward

Singapore’s relative openness and diversity of beliefs should be welcomed. Freedom of religion can coexist with freedom from religion, including the right to question, change or reject religious beliefs without prejudice.

Greater access to information has allowed younger Singaporeans to explore worldviews independently. Critical thinking and scientific literacy are essential safeguards against misinformation. Everyone should develop critical thinking and scientific literacy regardless of religious belief, or lack of. 

We agree with Dr Tay when he acknowledged that “Religion doesn’t have a monopoly on teaching moral education.” (at 37:50). We should therefore understand non-religious Singaporeans not merely by what they no longer believe, but by what they value, pursue and contribute to society.

We recognise Dr Tay’s concern about weakening community ties. Towards the end of the interview, he emphasised the importance of community. Religious institutions have historically provided belonging and mutual support, but these are not exclusive to religion. Volunteer organisations, hobby groups, sports clubs and secular associations also foster friendships, shared purpose and compassion.

Overall, as identities become stronger, Singapore still needs to guard against communities becoming isolated from one another. Strengthening shared spaces, where people cooperate regardless of backgrounds and affiliations, remain important.

The Humanist Society (Singapore) affirms that human challenges can be addressed through reason, evidence, empathy and collective action. We remain committed to providing a voice for non-religious Singaporeans while staying engaged with our shared spaces. 

Annex

Figures from the non-religious, extracted from the IPS working paper Religion in Singapore: The Private and Public Spheres

Why are the Humanist Society turnouts so small after so many years? Has it failed?

***

Over the years, people have given feedback that the Humanist Society (Singapore) struggles to scale up. Events are mostly small-group interactions, averaging about 15 to 30 attendees per event. While there are occasional bigger turnouts of 50-100 people, it usually happens only with collaborations with other groups, or comprise foreign delegates from abroad.

Indeed, while more than 20% of Singapore’s population identifies as having no religion, several cultural and structural factors keep the society’s physical turnouts small.

Cultural Context in Singapore

  • No Urgent “Push” Factor. Unlike countries where secular organizations grow out of pushback against religious laws or discrimination, Singapore’s secular governance already protects non-religious people in daily life. Most non-religious Singaporeans feel little urgency to organize around their lack of faith.
  • Lack of “Congregational” Habit. People who identify as non-religious or “freethinkers” in Singapore often do not feel a need for weekly communal gatherings or a church-like community structure.
  • Privacy and Social Caution. Discussing religion, atheism, or leaving a faith remains a sensitive topic for many Singaporeans, especially when navigating relationships with religious family members. Many prefer engaging with the society’s content quietly online—where it has accumulated over 10,000 followers and hundreds of thousands of video views—rather than attending in person.

Volunteer Bandwidth

  • All-Volunteer Operation. The society has no paid staff, meaning every meetup, panel, and newsletter is organized by committee members and volunteers balancing full-time jobs. Keeping physical events smaller and frequent (1 to 3 times a month) makes them sustainable without burning out organizers

Intentional Format and Venue Limits

  • Venue Constraints. As a volunteer-run organization funded primarily by $20 annual membership fees, the group hosts events in cafes, nature trails, or small rented spaces like rooms at OnePeople.sg, which naturally restricts capacity.
  • Deliberate Group Caps. Many of the society’s events are designed for intimate, open dialogue rather than large lectures. Sessions like Humanist Café or Death Café are explicitly capped at around 20 attendees to ensure everyone has space to speak.

Photo above: A Straits Times feature of the Society in 2011.

So, has the Society failed?

Whether the Humanist Society (Singapore) has “failed” depends entirely on what metric you use to judge it.

If you measure success by mass mobilization and large crowd sizes, its physical footprint looks very small given that almost 1 in 4 Singaporean residents are non-religious. However, if you evaluate it against its actual constitutional goals, it is generally considered a stable, niche community group rather than a failure.

Why It Is Not Considered a Failure

  • Consistent Execution of Its Core Mission: The society’s stated mission is to promote secularism, rational inquiry, and community among non-religious people in Singapore. By consistently running events, publishing educational materials, and maintaining its legal registration for over 16 years, it has fulfilled its basic mandate.
  • Surviving Volunteer Burnout: In Singapore, many interest groups and small civil society organizations dissolve within two to three years when founding members move on. Remaining active, debt-free, and operational since 2010 is a sign of institutional resilience.
  • Digital and Media Reach: Physical turnouts of 15–20 people do not reflect its wider footprint. Its online videos, articles, and social media channels reach tens of thousands of Singaporeans, and its representatives are occasionally consulted by local media or researchers regarding the non-religious demographic.

Where Critics Might See Limitations

  • Limited Mass Appeal: Despite roughly one in five Singaporeans identifying as having no religion, the society has not become a household name or a mass movement. Most non-religious Singaporeans remain unaffiliated and uninterested in joining an organized humanist group.
  • Niche Policy Influence: Because Singapore strictly regulates religious and political discourse to maintain social harmony, the society cannot engage in aggressive lobbying or confrontational activism. As a result, its direct influence on national policy remains modest compared to larger, established religious bodies.

Ultimately, the society operates more like a specialized interest club and support network than a mass political or social movement. For the core group of people seeking like-minded company, a non-religious voice for certain issues, and philosophical discussion, it serves its purpose well.

Teaming Up to Support the Fight Against Cancer

The HumanistSG team Hope Runners took part in the Singtel-Singapore Cancer Society Race Against Cancer 2026, raising $1,450 for cancer patients and their families!

Some Hope Runners after a group run
Some Hope Runners after a group run
Screenshot of team page
Screenshot of our team page

Participating in the Virtual Race category, Hope Runners ran and walked between 20 September and 15 October to support programmes of the Singapore Cancer Society. These programmes include medical support, counselling services and financial assistance for cancer patients and their families. This is the second year that Hope Runners has taken part in the Race Against Cancer.

Thanks to all those who cheered us on and donated to this meaningful cause!

Humanist Society (Singapore) Celebrates 16th Anniversary with “Stories from Afar”

On 17 October 2026, the Humanist Society (Singapore) (HSS) celebrated its 16th anniversary with “Stories from Afar”, an event featuring insights and experiences from two major international humanist gatherings in Luxembourg and Canada.

Moments from our anniversary:


***

HSS representatives Sree and Eugene shared highlights from the International Humanist Conference 2025 in Luxembourg City and the World Humanist Congress 2026 in Ottawa.

Their presentations explored how humanist organisations worldwide are promoting scientific literacy, defending human rights, strengthening secular communities and translating humanist values into practical action.

Promoting Scientific Literacy in Luxembourg

Held from 4 to 6 July 2025, the International Humanist Conference in Luxembourg brought together approximately 150 participants under the theme “From Awareness to Action: Strengthening Open Societies through Scientific Literacy”.

Two representatives – Sree and Eugene – attended this Conference.

At the Anniversary, they highlighted several innovative initiatives that made science more accessible to the public.

For example, the Romanian Secular Humanist Association developed science-themed calendars featuring significant discoveries and historical milestones. Rather than selling them, the organisation distributed the calendars to teachers to encourage curiosity and scientific learning among students.

Photos below, moments from the trip to Luxembourg:



***

Meanwhile, Humanistas Guatemala introduced “Science in a Box”, providing hands-on experiments in electricity, mechanics, optics and biology to children in rural communities with limited access to science education.

Another initiative involved Luxembourg-based science podcaster Hanna Siemaszko, who helps scientists and researchers communicate complex scientific concepts through engaging audio content.

The representatives also reflected on meeting Mubarak Bala, a Nigerian humanist activist who was imprisoned for four and a half years. His experience underscored the importance of international solidarity in defending freedom of belief and expression.

Humanism as Resistance in Ottawa

The World Humanist Congress, held from 7 to 9 August 2026 in Ottawa, attracted approximately 500 participants under the theme “Humanism as Resistance”. Three representatives – Lava, Eugene and Sree – attended this Congress.

Hosted by Humanist Canada, the Congress examined how humanists could respond to rising authoritarianism, religious nationalism and anti-science misinformation.

Photos below, moments from the trip to Ottawa:



***

One memorable session featured current and former parliamentarians from Iceland, Norway and the United Kingdom, who encouraged greater civic participation. Their central message was that meaningful change requires individuals to show up, get involved and persevere, even when progress appears slow.

Philosopher A.C. Grayling (below) reinforced this message in his closing keynote, distinguishing between wishful thinking and rational hope. He argued that genuine progress depends on critical thinking, community engagement and concrete action rather than simply hoping for improvement.

***

The representatives also highlighted Presto Misto, a community space and café established by Czech humanists in Prague. The initiative demonstrated how welcoming physical spaces could foster meaningful connections among non-religious individuals, particularly young people.

A spontaneous street encounter with a Christian evangelist provided another memorable lesson. What began as a disagreement eventually became a respectful exchange, with participants acknowledging one another’s freedom of belief and non-belief.

Risk of dogmaticism?

Commenting on his experience at Ottawa, Lava expressed concerns that humanism risks becoming dogmatic when it shifts from being a philosophy and outlook on life into a rigid identity defined by adherence to prescribed values. Reflecting on his experience at the humanist conference, Lava drew parallels between the promotion of humanist values and religious teachings. “If you don’t adhere to the ‘humanist’ values, you’re probably not a humanist,” he observed.

He also cautioned against conflating ideas with moral values, where challenging an idea could be perceived as attacking the values associated with it. “Because it’s easier to defend values than to defend ideas,” he argued, such an approach risks shielding ideas from legitimate criticism.

Lava warned that this tendency could undermine humanism’s commitment to freedom of speech, dissent and intellectual openness, reducing these principles to “lip service for the bare minimum”. He expressed concern that humanism could develop the same dogmatic tendencies it criticises in religion.

***

Strengthening International Humanist Connections

Both conferences included General Assemblies of Humanists International, the global umbrella organisation representing more than 120 member organisations and associated groups.

Notable developments included the election of Maggie Ardiente as President in 2025, the adoption of the Luxembourg Declaration on AI and Human Values, and the Ottawa Declaration on “Humanism as Resistance” in 2026.

Reflecting on their experiences at the Anniversary, the HSS representatives emphasised the importance of grassroots initiatives, youth engagement, scientific literacy and active participation in public life. They also recognised that humanist communities face different challenges depending on their local circumstances.

Other moments at the Anniversary:



***

As a longstanding member of Humanists International, HSS has participated in international gatherings for more than a decade and hosted regional conferences in Singapore in 2015, 2019, 2024.

The anniversary sharing highlighted how exchanges with humanists worldwide can inspire local initiatives and strengthen a shared commitment to reason, evidence and compassion.

The next World Humanist Congress is scheduled to take place in Lima, Peru, in 2027.

Support our Member, Neo Sree, at the 2026 Virtual Asian Humanist Conference

This weekend, 03 Oct (Sat), one of our Humanist Society (Singapore) members, Neo Sree, will be speaking at the 2026 Virtual Asian Humanist Conference. His topic is “How I found and joined the Humanism movement”

He is scheduled to speak between 415-430pm (Singapore Time), 08:15–08:30 (UTC)

You are warmly invited to sign up for the Conference in support of him. Sign up here: https://us06web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_X-qGvVpHSiCXmoqsU3i5wQ#/registration

Full details of the Virtual Asian Humanist Conference, hosted by Humanists Malaysia from 03-04 Oct: https://www.humanistsmalaysia.org/conference

Space for Spirituality in Secular Singapore? – Research Findings and Shared Reflections

***

This gathering by Robin Weber, PhD Candidate and Psychological Researcher at James Cook University (Singapore Campus) was an open and collaborative exploration into non-religious spirituality in Singapore, examine the data and results of his ongoing doctoral research studying how spirituality is understood and practised in an increasingly secular society.

Spirituality is defined as “the personal quest for understanding answers to ultimate questions about life,” distinguishing it from organised religion. The study responds to a global increase in nonreligion but lack of research conducted in the Asia-Pacific region – where almost one-quarter of the world’s nonreligious population lives. This risks overlooking spiritual diversity, for example, compared with Europe, a much larger proportion of Singapore’s non-religious population identifies as “spiritual but not religious” (SBNR) and holds implicit spiritual beliefs.

Photo below: Robin speaking to a large crowd.

***

The presentation was centered on the speaker’s qualitative study in Singapore involving participants from diverse walks of life. After outlining the analysis’ six major themes, the room discussed each of them in groups to interpret, reflect and personally apply the implications of the findings. Guiding interview questions and excerpts from the interviews were shared with the groups to facilitate their conversations. Some of the topics participants talked about involved:

  • Connection with oneself, others, nature, and the wider world.
  • Belief in realities beyond the physical world, including higher powers, cosmic principles, an afterlife, etc.
  • Personalised spiritual practices that promote calmness and self-control.
  • Linking happiness with helping others, and community engagement.
  • Searching for meaning and purpose with spiritual guidance.
  • Freedom to choose one’s own path, emphasising autonomy, rationality, and individual agency.

***

An overarching finding is that identity underpins all six themes. Spirituality appears to be an important source of identity for many nonreligious people, yet Singapore’s blend of secularism is often perceived as an obstacle for spiritual expressions outside of religion. Robin reflected the interactions made him think whether dedicated spiritual spaces were desired to offer safe environments for people to explore otherwise often stigmatised beliefs. The presentation concluded with an  outlook on Robin’s future quantitative research.

Reflections on Singapore’s move towards non-religiosity

This is a commentary by the Executive Committee, Humanist Society (Singapore). The key driver of non-religiosity is diversity of information. However, misconceptions about non-religiosity persist and for some who left their faith, the social cost is real.

***

The latest General Household Survey 2025 showed that 23.9% of residents had no religious affiliation in 2025, up from 20% in 2020 and 18.5% in 2015.

This indicates an accelerating uptick in Singapore’s non-religious population, as 3.9% is more than double that of the previous 5 year intervals. Back in 1980, 13% were non-religious, showing that non-religiosity is not new. In fact, this demographic likely predates independence and has always been part of Singapore.

While there are many non-religious people/residents in Singapore from all walks of life, few organisations are dedicated to studying and building communities for the non-religious. The Humanist Society (Singapore) is one such organisation.

Over the years, we have engaged more than 7,000 non-religious individuals through our 300+ events, documenting many personal stories and perspectives. Based on this experience, we offer the following observations:

1) The key driver of non-religiosity is diversity of information

(Above) Asian Humanism Conference 2015, held in Singapore.

Some see non-religiosity as “another religion”, attributing its rise to active promotion. Others blame Westernisation, materialism, moral relativism, or even speculate about devil worship.

Our experience suggests otherwise. People leave religion—or remain non-religious—for many reasons. Some gradually find religious rituals less relevant. Others leave because certain teachings no longer align with their values.

One key factor in this shift is access to diversity of information. The internet exposes people to different religions, philosophies and worldviews. Humanity’s search for meaning is now accessible with a tap on the phone.

Increasingly, people evaluate beliefs critically instead of accepting them at face value. They build their principles from ideas they find most convincing, regardless of culture or religion. Over time, identifying with a particular religion becomes less meaningful, and many simply consider themselves non-religious.

2) Misconceptions about non-religiosity persist

For many, religion is the foundation of morality. This belief is often reinforced through lifelong teachings, while some religious texts portray non-believers negatively.

As a result, some continue to believe that non-religious people lack morality because, without God, nothing restrains immoral behaviour. They may even attribute crime, war and other social problems to godlessness, despite correlation not implying causation.

There is, however, no definitive evidence that being non-religious or atheist makes a person immoral. Multiple studies show that countries with high proportions of non-religious people also perform well on measures such as low crime, prosperity, equality, freedom, democracy, women’s rights, human rights, education and life expectancy. Examples include Sweden, Denmark, Norway, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Uruguay, Japan, Britain, France, the Netherlands, Germany, South Korea, New Zealand and Australia.

This is not to suggest that non-religiosity itself reduces crime. Strong education, effective law enforcement and many other factors also play essential roles. This is something that Singapore as a secular state has achieved since independence because of our strong rule of law and efforts to foster social cohesion. 

3) For some who left their faith, the social cost is real  

From our engagement with the non-religious, those from highly devout or conservative families often face strong opposition after leaving their faith, frequently because of the misconceptions described above in 2).

For those who left their faith, even if they remain kind and well-intentioned, their decision may be seen as rejecting their family’s or community’s identity. In some cases, these relationships never recover.

It is therefore important for those who left their faith, especially those who become non-religious, to have social support networks such as the Humanist Society. It is equally important that their experiences are acknowledged and represented, including in interfaith dialogue. Their pain should not be ignored out of fear of offending others.

(Above) One of the numerous support sessions organised by the Humanist Society (Singapore).

4) Most non-religious people genuinely do not believe in God or consider themselves spiritual

A common response to the growing non-religious population is that they are “still religious”, “culturally religious”, “spiritual”, or simply “temporarily lost”. We sometimes get the sense that people wish to keep them within their religious fold.

While some non-religious people continue to hold supernatural, theistic or spiritual beliefs, our experience is that most do not.

This is supported by this Institute of Policy Studies (IPS) working paper, which found that among non-religious respondents, 65% neither followed a religion nor considered themselves spiritual, while 68.1% did not believe in God.

Source: Pg 28, IPS Working Papers No.33, “Religion in Singapore: The Private and Public Spheres”, published in 2019.

Source: Pg 34, IPS Working Papers No.33, “Religion in Singapore: The Private and Public Spheres”, published in 2019. 

5) The non-religious contribute positively to interfaith dialogue and religious harmony

The Humanist Society (Singapore) supports and has taken part in interfaith dialogues to strengthen understanding among religious communities as well as between religious and non-religious people. We support Singapore’s model of secularism, which provides space for diverse belief systems while ensuring public policy benefits all Singaporeans regardless of race or religion.

Our longstanding positions include:

  • Disagreements over beliefs should be resolved through dialogue rather than police reports or legal action.
  • Every individual has the right to hold and express their beliefs. At the same time, no belief should be beyond scrutiny or discussion. In the pursuit of truth and a better world, all ideas should be examined for logical soundness and tested against the best available evidence.

(Above) An interfaith visit to a mosque, organised by the Humanist Society (Singapore) in 2024.

Concluding thoughts 

Freedom from religion should also be part of freedom of religion.

Sadly, being non-religious, particularly atheist, is illegal or dangerous in many countries. The fact that 23.9% of Singapore residents can openly identify as non-religious reflects Singapore’s success in building a forward-looking, multiracial and multireligious society. Freedom from religion is something to be proud of, not feared or viewed with disdain. 

The Humanist Society (Singapore) will continue to monitor developments in this area and serve as a voice and refuge for the non-religious.

Response to the New Committee on Strengthening the Singapore Indian Community

We refer to the Straits Times article, “New committee starts work to strengthen Indian community’s identity, youth and vulnerable groups” (Apr 25, 2026) where it was reported that one of the early areas of work for a new committee to strengthen the Singapore Indian community includes partnering religious organisations to support inmates and their families, as part of broader efforts to uplift vulnerable groups.

https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/new-committee-on-strengthening-indian-community-begins-work-to-support-inmates-families

We acknowledge and appreciate efforts by the government to bring the Indian community closer together and move forward.

However, we are concerned that religion is being prioritized as the means to help reduce reoffending among Indian inmates.

While religion can play an important role in motivating people who are already religious, not everyone in the country is religious. As of the 2020 census, one in five Singaporeans are non-religious. There is a diverse range of beliefs in Singapore, including within the Indian community. And the non-religious are present everywhere.

There is also a diversity of interpretations within each religious community.

Inmate rehabilitation should prioritize evidence-based, secular methods that can be generically applied to people from any background. This will help avoid any indirect proselytization and any perceived coercion, a prudent approach to maintain religious and racial harmony in secular Singapore. At the same time, religious inmates who specifically request and agree to religious rehabilitation should be given the freedom to receive them.

We urge the government to adjust this approach in inmate rehabilitation. The Humanist Society remains open to dialogue on better, evidence-based and secular solutions.

Secular Assembly / Darwin Day (28 February 2026) – The Evolution of the Darwin–Wallace Story: From History to Pop Science Mythology

The Evolution of the Darwin–Wallace Story: From History to Pop Science Mythology

Our guest speaker on this topic was Dr John van Wyhe, a British historian of science at the National University of Singapore, specialising in Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace.

At this Secular Assembly, he spoke about an ongoing debate among historians concerning two different interpretations of Wallace’s historical role. One group of historians believes that Wallace was an underestimated scholar who was overshadowed by other scientists of his time because he came from a poor background. In contrast to Darwin, who came from a wealthy family and had many opportunities, Wallace is often portrayed as someone who lacked similar advantages.

Dr John explained very convincingly that he supports the opposing view: namely, that this interpretation is not supported by the historical evidence. Based on extensive research, he came to the conclusion that Wallace published only a fraction of what Darwin published during their lifetimes. Using this example, he demonstrated how modern science — and in this case parts of the historical community — sometimes tend to promote certain narratives even when there is little evidence to support them. According to him, there is often a tendency to favour underdog stories rather than focus strictly on documented facts.

He also presented other examples showing that this tendency to elevate underdog narratives has appeared repeatedly in the past, for instance in comparisons between Nikola Tesla and Thomas Edison.

In summary, it was a delightful afternoon, and everyone especially appreciated the strong message behind the talk. We hope to welcome Dr John again soon. Read more about Dr John’s works at: https://darwin-online.org.uk/people/van_wyhe.html and https://wallace-online.org/

Other highlights of the programme:

Before the main Assembly, a group of attendees enjoyed a guided tour of the Harmony in Diversity Gallery, kindly made possible by our gallery partners.

Dan, the presenter of the Assembly, invited participants to join him in a guided imaginary journey to reflect on things we are grateful for.

We also enjoyed a lively singalong and had the opportunity to ask questions about the topic, which Dr John answered in great detail.

Secular Assembly – 27 December 2025

If life were a game, what kind of main character would you be? At our last Secular Assembly of 2025, this question was explored by our guest speaker amid a festive and reflective atmosphere.

In a presentation titled “Embracing Your Protagonism”, guest speaker Melvin Lim, President of HSS, discussed how one might use the lenses of storytelling and games to navigate a complex world.

Starting with an overview of folklore around the world related to winter, Melvin helped situate Christmas traditions within a vibrant tapestry of cultures with origins ranging from Japan to Europe.

Like folklore that can convey important moral and practical knowledge, narrative games, Melvin posited, is one lens we could use to navigate our lives. Some questions raised by his presentation:

  • Do you prefer a ‘restricted’ environment (where there is a specific condition to ‘win’, such as in chess) or a ‘free’ one (where the success criterion is self-defined, such as in Minecraft)?
  • Are you more ‘autotelic’ (motivated by intrinsic factors such as curiosity) or ‘exotelic’ (motivated by external factors such as prestige)?
  • How are you nurturing your talent, and improving your luck (which can be thought of as a combination of opportunity and preparedness)?

Other highlights of the programme:

  • Before the main Assembly, a group of attendees enjoyed a guided tour of the Harmony in Diversity gallery, kindly made possible by our gallery partners. Read more about the gallery here.
  • Lit by (electronic) candlelight, participants were guided to share reflections on things that they were grateful for over the past year.
  • The jolliest fellow of the season dropped by! Santa Claus surprised attendees with presents and led us in a medley of classic Christmas songs.

Join us at the next Secular Assembly, where we’ll continue to build the Humanist community!